Loading…
CleanMyMac vs AppCleaner
Which is the better utilities for Mac in 2026?
We compared CleanMyMac and AppCleaner across 5 key factors including price, open-source status, and community adoption. Both CleanMyMac and AppCleaner are excellent utilities. Read our full breakdown below.
CleanMyMac
Tool to remove unnecessary files and folders from disk
Free
VS
AppCleaner
Thoroughly uninstall unwanted apps
Free
Visual Comparison
AppCleaner
AppCleaner — Official Website
Our Verdict
Both CleanMyMac and AppCleaner are excellent utilities. CleanMyMac is better for users who prefer polished experiences, while AppCleaner excels for those who value established ecosystems.
Feature Comparison
| Feature | CleanMyMac | AppCleaner |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free | Free |
| Open Source | No | No |
| Monthly Installs | N/A | N/A |
| GitHub Stars | N/A | N/A |
| Category | System Utilities | System Utilities |
Quick Install
CleanMyMac
brew install --cask cleanmymacAppCleaner
brew install --cask appcleanerLearn More
In-Depth Overview
What is CleanMyMac X?
CleanMyMac X, developed by MacPaw, has evolved by 2026 into the premier utility suite for macOS, certified by Apple and used by millions globally. Born in 2008 as a simple cleaner, it has grown into a sophisticated 'Control Center' for Mac health. It combines over 30 separate tools into a single, cohesive interface known for its heavy use of fluid animations and user-friendly design. The core philosophy of CleanMyMac X is 'Smart Scan,' a one-click solution that analyzes the system for junk (cache, logs, broken logins), potential security threats (malware, adware, ransomware), and performance bottlenecks (hung apps, heavy memory consumers). Beyond cleaning, it features a full-fledged uninstaller, a software updater that checks for the latest versions of your apps (even those not from the App Store), and a 'Space Lens' feature that visualizes storage. In 2026, it integrates seamlessly with macOS Sequoia and newer iterations, utilizing Neural Engine capabilities to identify junk files with higher precision than ever before. It runs a background 'Menu' app that provides real-time health monitoring of CPU, battery, and network speeds, positioning itself not just as a janitor, but as a dashboard for your computer's vitals.
What is AppCleaner?
AppCleaner, developed by FreeMacSoft, stands as a testament to the longevity of high-quality freeware in the Mac ecosystem. For over a decade and continuing into 2026, it has remained a lightweight, single-purpose utility that does exactly what its name implies: it cleans apps. When a user drags an application icon into the AppCleaner window, the software instantly scans the system for all associated files—preferences, cache folders, launch agents, and containers—that would normally be left behind if the app were simply dragged to the Trash. Its interface is intentionally Spartan, featuring a small window with a drag-and-drop zone and a list view of installed applications, widgets, and plugins. It does not run background processes, it does not nag for updates, and it does not try to upsell features. Its 'SmartDelete' feature can be toggled to detect when an app is moved to the Trash manually, offering to clean up leftovers automatically. In an era of bloated software, AppCleaner remains a favorite among Mac purists because it respects the user's resources, occupying only a few megabytes of space and requiring zero CPU cycles when not in active use.
Detailed Feature Comparison
App Uninstallation Deep-Clean
CriticalCleanMyMacExcellent
CleanMyMac X provides a visually rich uninstaller module. It categorizes software by vendor, store source, and usage frequency (identifying unused apps). When you select an app, it hunts down binaries, containers, preferences, and supporting files. Crucially, it can also remove 'Leftovers'—files from apps you deleted incorrectly in the past. It handles complex uninstalls, including 32-bit legacy apps and suspended applications, with a safety database that prevents the removal of critical system files.
AppCleanerExcellent
AppCleaner matches CleanMyMac in the core capability of finding associated files. Its detection algorithm is fast and accurate, locating plist files, application support folders, and caches instantly. The 'SmartDelete' daemon is a standout feature; if enabled, it watches the Trash. If you delete an app the 'Apple way' (drag to Trash), AppCleaner pops up and asks if you want to remove the associated junk files, keeping the workflow seamless.
Verdict: CleanMyMac X wins slightly due to its ability to find 'Leftovers' from previously deleted apps and its categorization features.
System Junk Removal
HighCleanMyMacExcellent
This is CleanMyMac's bread and butter. It scans deep into system folders to remove user cache, system logs, language files (localization data you don't need), universal binaries (removing Intel code on M-series Macs), and broken login items. In 2026, its 'Smart Scan' safely reclaims gigabytes of space that manual cleaning would miss, all while adhering to Apple's notarization safety standards to ensure no OS-critical files are touched.
AppCleanerLimited
AppCleaner is strictly an app uninstaller. It does not scan for system-wide junk, language files, or general system caches unrelated to specific applications. If you want to clear your browser cache or remove old iOS backups, AppCleaner cannot help you. It relies on the user to manually identify which apps are taking up space rather than offering a system-wide cleaning solution.
Verdict: CleanMyMac X is the clear winner as AppCleaner does not offer general system junk removal.
Malware Detection & Removal
HighCleanMyMacGood
CleanMyMac X includes a dedicated 'Malware Removal' module powered by Moonlock Engine. It scans for macOS-specific threats including adware, ransomware, spyware, and cryptocurrency miners. While not as robust as a dedicated enterprise antivirus, it is perfect for consumer protection. It offers real-time background monitoring to block threats before they execute and regularly updates its virus database to catch 2026-era threats.
AppCleanerLimited
AppCleaner has zero security features. It treats malware applications just like any other app. While you can use it to uninstall a malicious app if you know what it is, AppCleaner will not detect the threat, warn you about it, or ensure that deeply hidden malicious rootkits are removed. It is a passive tool, not an active defender.
Verdict: CleanMyMac X wins by default as it includes active security protection, whereas AppCleaner is purely a utility.
Background Monitoring (Menu Bar)
MediumCleanMyMacExcellent
The CleanMyMac X Menu app is a comprehensive dashboard living in your status bar. It displays real-time CPU load, memory pressure, battery health cycles, network speed, and connected devices (including iPhone/iPad battery levels). It also provides quick shortcuts to free up RAM or empty the trash. In 2026, this menu is highly customizable and integrates with macOS widgets for desktop visibility.
AppCleanerLimited
AppCleaner does not have a menu bar icon or system monitor. Its only background integration is the optional 'SmartDelete' feature, which runs invisibly and only activates when an application is moved to the Trash. This fits its philosophy of being lightweight, but it lacks the real-time system insight that CMM offers.
Verdict: CleanMyMac X offers a rich, informative dashboard, while AppCleaner remains intentionally invisible.
Software Updater
MediumCleanMyMacGood
The Updater module in CleanMyMac X aggregates updates for both App Store apps and direct-download apps. This is a significant convenience, as macOS natively handles App Store updates well but often neglects third-party tools. It provides a single list of all outdated software and allows for one-click bulk updating, ensuring you have the latest features and security patches without visiting multiple websites.
AppCleanerLimited
AppCleaner does not track software versions or offer updates. It assumes the user will manage updates through the App Store or the applications' own auto-update mechanisms. Its role is strictly the removal of software, not the maintenance or updating of the existing software library.
Verdict: CleanMyMac X simplifies software management by centralizing updates, a feature completely absent in AppCleaner.
Space Visualization
MediumCleanMyMacExcellent
The 'Space Lens' feature builds a visual map of your storage, representing folders as bubbles of varying sizes. This allows users to intuitively spot large, forgotten files or folders deep in the directory structure. It acts similarly to tools like DaisyDisk, allowing you to browse your drive visually and mark massive files for deletion without needing to navigate the Finder's list views.
AppCleanerFair
AppCleaner creates a list of installed applications sorted by size, which helps identify large apps. However, it cannot visualize the entire hard drive or find large files that aren't applications (like video projects or archives). It is limited to the scope of installed applications, widgets, and plugins only.
Verdict: CleanMyMac X provides a full-disk visualization tool, whereas AppCleaner only lists application sizes.
Ease of Use / Interface
HighCleanMyMacExcellent
MacPaw is renowned for UI/UX design. CleanMyMac X features satisfying micro-animations, clear typography, and a very guided 'hand-holding' experience. It explains what it is doing at every step, making it accessible to complete novices. The 'Smart Scan' button is massive and impossible to miss, making the entry barrier non-existent for non-technical users.
AppCleanerExcellent
AppCleaner utilizes a 'drag-and-drop' interface that is the epitome of Mac simplicity. There are no menus to navigate; you simply drag an app to the window, and it does the rest. It is arguably faster to use for a single uninstallation because there is no scanning of the whole system required. Its simplicity is its greatest strength, with zero learning curve.
Verdict: AppCleaner wins for pure simplicity and speed; it requires fewer clicks to perform its primary function.
Performance & Resource Usage
MediumCleanMyMacGood
While highly optimized for Apple Silicon, CleanMyMac X is a large suite. It runs background helpers for health monitoring, malware scanning, and update checking. While the impact is negligible on modern M3/M4 chips, it does consume more system resources (RAM and CPU cycles) than a passive utility. Users on very old hardware might feel a slight footprint.
AppCleanerExcellent
AppCleaner is effectively weightless. It occupies a tiny amount of disk space and uses zero CPU or RAM when the application window is closed (unless SmartDelete is active, which is still negligible). It launches instantly and closes instantly. For users obsessed with keeping their activity monitor clear of background processes, AppCleaner is superior.
Verdict: AppCleaner is the winner for system resource efficiency, having virtually zero footprint.
Who Should Choose Which?
1The New Mac Convert
CleanMyMac
Users switching from Windows are often terrified of breaking their new expensive machine and are used to 'System Optimizers.' CleanMyMac X provides a comforting, guided interface that explains every action. It helps them manage storage without understanding the complex macOS file structure (Library, Containers, etc.) and provides a safety net against malware, which is a common concern for new users. The subscription is worth the peace of mind and education it provides about the system.
2The Minimalist Developer
AppCleaner
Developers often install and uninstall tools daily to test environments. They hate bloatware and background processes that steal CPU cycles from compiling code. AppCleaner is the perfect tool for this persona. It sits quietly in the Applications folder, launches instantly via Spotlight, deletes the target app and its config files, and closes. It doesn't nag, it doesn't scan, and it doesn't cost money. It fits perfectly into a highly optimized, keyboard-centric workflow.
3The Digital Hoarder
CleanMyMac
This user has a 512GB SSD that is constantly full. They don't know why. They have apps from 2019 they haven't opened. CleanMyMac X is essential here for two features: 'Space Lens' and 'Unused Apps' filter. Space Lens visualizes where the data is hiding (usually in forgotten cache folders or old iPhone backups), and the Uninstaller identifies apps that haven't been launched in years. AppCleaner helps remove apps, but it doesn't help the user *find* what to remove.
4The Enterprise IT Admin
AppCleaner
An IT admin managing 50 Macs for a small business needs tools that are free, require no licensing management, and are safe for users to handle. Installing AppCleaner on every machine provides a standard way for employees to remove software without leaving clutter. It avoids the recurring cost of 50 CleanMyMac licenses ($2000+/year) while still maintaining a basic level of system hygiene. It prevents the 'Application Support' folder from bloating over time on company machines.
5The Privacy Advocate
CleanMyMac
This might seem counter-intuitive as CMM is a cloud-connected app, but CleanMyMac X has specific 'Privacy' modules. It allows users to instantly wipe browser history, cookies, and chat data across all browsers (Safari, Chrome, Firefox) in one click. It also manages application permissions. For a user who wants to ensure their digital footprint on the machine is wiped regularly without manually clearing every browser's history settings, CMM X offers a centralized privacy dashboard.
6The Budget Student
AppCleaner
Students often have limited budgets and limited disk space (entry-level MacBook Airs). They need to keep their Mac clean, but $40/year is a few weeks of coffee or a textbook. AppCleaner solves the primary issue of removing old games or large education software completely without cost. Combined with manual cache clearing (which can be learned), AppCleaner allows the student to maintain a healthy Mac without spending a dime. It is the responsible financial choice.
Migration Guide
Cleanmymac → Appcleaner
Transitioning from CleanMyMac X to AppCleaner is essentially a shift from 'Automatic' to 'Manual' maintenance. First, use CleanMyMac X one last time to fully uninstall itself (ironically, it's good at this) or use AppCleaner to remove CMM. Once you switch, you will lose the automatic malware scanning and system junk cleaning. You will need to install AppCleaner. Moving forward, you must remember to drag apps to AppCleaner rather than the Trash. You will also need to find alternative ways to clear system cache (booting into Safe Mode occasionally does this) and check for malware (using the free version of Malwarebytes, for example). You save money, but you take on more responsibility for the system's health.
Appcleaner → Cleanmymac
Moving from AppCleaner to CleanMyMac X is an upgrade in scope. You are moving from a single tool to a suite. After installing CMM X, the first step is to run a full Smart Scan. This will likely find gigabytes of 'System Junk' that AppCleaner never touched (user cache, logs, language files). You should enable the CMM Menu bar item to replace any other system monitors you used. You can uninstall AppCleaner using CleanMyMac X, as CMM's uninstaller fully covers the functionality of AppCleaner. Enjoy the automation; you no longer need to worry about hunting for leftover files manually, as the CMM background monitor will alert you whenever you trash an app.
Pro Tips
Regardless of which tool you use, the most important migration tip is to check your 'Login Items' in System Settings. When switching tools, often the old helper agents remain. Ensure you revoke Full Disk Access for the old tool and grant it to the new one to ensure deep cleaning capabilities. Also, review your backup strategy; cleaning tools are powerful and having a Time Machine backup before a major switch is mandatory.
Final Verdict
Overall Winner
CleanMyMac X
9.2/10
Winner
8.8/10
Runner-up
CleanMyMac X wins the comparison for 2026 because it answers the question 'How do I keep my Mac healthy?' comprehensively. It combines the functionality of AppCleaner with an antivirus, a system optimizer, a disk visualizer, and an updater. It transforms maintenance from a chore into a one-click automated process. While AppCleaner is a flawless utility for what it does—and earns a perfect score for value—it is a screwdriver compared to CleanMyMac's Swiss Army Knife. For the modern user facing modern threats and storage clutter, the suite approach of CleanMyMac X offers superior long-term value despite the price tag.
Bottom Line: If you are willing to pay for premium peace of mind and comprehensive tools, buy CleanMyMac X; if you simply want to delete apps for free, download AppCleaner.
Video Tutorials
AppCleaner Walkthrough and Review
Breelabs • 5.5K views
How to Uninstall Apps on Macbook
CleanMyMac by MacPaw • 334.1K views
Essential Mac App #1 - AppCleaner
MacProTips • 6.9K views
Learn to uninstall Apps in Mac #mymactalk #macbook #ios #apple
My Mac Talk • 429.0K views
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, AppCleaner is very safe. It operates on a simple principle: it reads the 'Bill of Materials' inside an application package and searches for files with matching bundle identifiers (like com.dropbox.client). It presents a list of files it intends to delete before it deletes them, giving the user final approval. It does not modify system files or touch the macOS kernel. However, users should always glance at the list of files to be deleted to ensure it hasn't accidentally grabbed a file they want to keep, though this is extremely rare with its specific detection algorithms.
About the Author
Productivity & Workflow Analyst
Productivity ApplicationsNote-Taking & Knowledge ManagementTask & Project Management
8+ years in operations management · PMP certified
Explore More on Bundl
Browse System Utilities apps, read our complete guide, or discover curated bundles.